Having grown up in a home where coffee was purchased in large cans of pre-ground beans, and working in a campus coffee shop that brewed from individual, pre-measured packets of grounds, this was an incredibly novel concept to me. It opened my eyes to a whole new world of buying coffee. No longer did I have to settle for those squishy pre-ground bags. Now I could venture into the world of whole bean coffee.
The coffee section at Trader Joe's was an adventure in itself. Their cans of coffee were tall with aesthetically pleasing packaging and funky-sounding names like "Costa Rica Tarrazu" and "Bali Blue Moon." My absolute favorite though was their Volcano coffee, which was considered a "Super Dark" roasted coffee. I knew little about different types and varietals of coffees, but I knew I liked a rich, bold brew that would bring out the flavors of my vanilla soy milk or peppermint mocha creamers. You could say that I liked a little coffee with my cream.

My tastes have evolved over the years. When I entered the specialty coffee world, I was introduced to light roasted coffees and taught how to pick out different tasting notes. The character of a light roasted coffee is often much more interesting than a dark roasted coffee. Dark roasts always have that smoky, burnt taste to them that often overpowers any other qualities of the coffee. Many specialty coffee shops these days won't even roast their coffee darker than a medium roast. Modern roasters tend to believe that this burnt taste ruins the coffee.
They have a point, but in the end, it all depends on personal preference. Like I said, I used to love that dark, rich, oily flavor of coffee, but when I learned more about the roasting process and how the process can bring out or mute the flavor characteristics of a coffee, I got caught up in the delightful taste sensation that is properly light roasted coffees. And I never really went back.
Recently though, when I began really excitedly writing about coffees on a regular basis, my husband noticed how happy it made me and decided to splurge on a super-rare (i.e. expensive) coffee for me to taste and write about. The coffee was described on the website as a medium roast, but turned out to be what I would consider a dark roast. Still, it was roasted fresh and shipped whole bean, so I was optimistic if a little wary.
This coffee, he told me, was a Green Tipped Bourbon (bourbon as used here is a type of coffee plant, not the whiskey!) from the island of St. Helena, and I'm terrible at geography, so I kept thinking Mount St. Helena, which is also a volcano, but is in the state of Washington, and even though coffee thrives in volcanic soil, it also needs a tropical climate. He tried to explain where the island of St. Helena is, that it's where Napoleon was exiled, and I'm thinking, "Isn't that near France?"
No, no it's not.
Thanks to Google, I was able to see that this extremely remote island is located in the south Atlantic Ocean, between the coasts of South America and Africa, but closer to Africa. It is a volcanic, tropical island, like Hawaii, though much much smaller. Like Hawaii, the conditions are perfect for growing delicious coffee, but coffee from St. Helena is even more rare than the beloved Hawaiian Kona because they aren't able to grow much on such a tiny piece of land.
So, knowing how rare (and expensive!) this coffee is made me very curious to try it. The darkness of the beans worried me--I was afraid it would just taste burnt. But this company, Coffee & Tea Limited, has been around a long time. Though they tend to roast darker than newer roasters, they delivered a classic, consistent batch of beans.
It took me a few sips to get past the smokiness, but when I opened my mind, my taste buds followed suit. It was smoky and sweet, with a smooth caramel ribbon of delight flowing quietly through the richness. It was delicious, and full of flavor. Each cup I brewed revealed a new layer of flavors, tasting almost like candy. The wonder never ceased, and even increased by the last sip, leading me to do some more research on this magical lava.
I learned that the Green Tipped Bourbon is still believed to be a pure strain of coffee straight from the Yemeni port of Mocha. And while the conditions on St. Helena are optimal for growing great coffee, the coffee still requires great care to produce a quality crop. There has been neglect of the coffee on the island in recent years that led to smaller and less delicious crops, but the farming seems to be on the up and up. Still, because it is such a small island (seriously, Google the Island of St. Helena--it's fascinating that this place is even occupied and civilized, it's so tiny and remote!), not much can be grown, and the rare delectable beans fetch about $89 per pound from roasters. My dear husband splurged on a 4 oz bag for me, and the kind people of Coffee & Tea Limited threw in a 4 oz sample bag of some coffee from El Salvador for free!
Ultimately, while I was skeptical about the beans being dark roasted, this coffee experience was truly a treasure for me. I learned a lot about geography, about one of the most remote civilized islands in the world, and about how much my husband cared to give me a coffee experience I didn't even know I wanted.
If you ever have a chance to try coffee from the Island of St. Helena, do it!